Stark&Cie
EN Language: English

Writing · Partnership

Chemistry is due diligence

Noam Wasserman found that 65% of high-potential startups fail because of conflict among co-founders. So we check the people before we read the plan.

Two glasses with an amber drink and ice

Noam Wasserman, then at Harvard Business School, studied 10,000 founders for his book The Founder’s Dilemmas. His most quoted finding: 65% of high-potential startups fail because of conflict among the co-founders. The problem sat at the top.

Paul Graham saw the same pattern from the other side. In October 2006, a year and a half after starting Y Combinator, he wrote that about 20% of the startups YC had funded had already lost a founder. It happened so often, he said, that YC reversed its attitude to vesting.

Investors check the wrong things

Venture firms spend weeks on due diligence. Lawyers read the cap table and accountants the numbers, and someone checks the code. Then the founders spend an hour in a conference room performing a pitch they have rehearsed 40 times, and everybody calls that the people check.

Some investors know better. CNN reported in 2014 on a Seattle angel who walked away from a startup because one co-founder shifted uncomfortably through his partner’s whole presentation and then corrected every slip. A New York investor ended a breakfast early after watching two founders interrupt each other. Six months later their partnership fell apart.

Five things we look for

We look at five things before we look at the plan: personal click, chemistry, energy, skills and character.

Personal click is simple. Do we want to spend the next ten years with these people? A hard first evening rarely gets easier by the tenth year.

Chemistry is about the founders among themselves and with us. We like to disagree with them early and watch how they handle it. If dinner is still pleasant afterwards, that is a good sign.

Energy is what is left on a bad day. We can bring money and contacts. We cannot bring drive.

Skills means that one of the founders can build the product. Design, structure and finance we can help with.

Character is how people treat those who cannot help them: suppliers, the first hire who did not work out, the investor who said no.

Why it is not soft

This is risk management. A business plan can be rewritten in a weekend. A founding team cannot. Wasserman’s data says the biggest risk in an early company sits at the top of the organisation chart, so that is where we spend most of our time.

It is also why we would rather meet over a drink than over a projector. People are more themselves at a table.

Sources

  1. CNN Money: Fighting co-founders doom startups, 24 February 2014
  2. Paul Graham: The 18 Mistakes That Kill Startups, October 2006
  3. Noam Wasserman: The Founder’s Dilemmas, Princeton University Press, 2012

More writing